The European Commission has formally opened proceedings against Spain because of the sanctions it enacted against five low-cost airlines over cabin baggage fees. The penalized airlines include Ryanair, Vueling, EasyJet, Norwegia, and Volotea. The Spanish authority fined these carriers for charging passengers for services like carry-on luggage, seat assignments, and boarding pass printing.
Spain’s consumer authority fined a combined €179 million for what it described as “abusive practices.” The Commission contends these penalties conflict with EU law, which grants airlines freedom to set their fares.
Brussels has a different take on this. The commission argues that, although the Court of Justice of the European Union has ruled that baggage must, in principle, be free of charge, this guarantee must respect reasonable requirements relating to the weight, dimensions, and security of the baggage.
The move signals a fresh clash between national consumer regulation and EU rules on airline pricing.
The Legal Fight Over Hand Luggage Fees
Consumer advocacy groups, notably BEUC, have supported Spain’s consumer ministry, moving to charge the airlines for violating passenger rights by monetising “standard” hand luggage. Airline associations, however, have pushed back. They argue that additional bag fees remain within their commercial discretion under EU Regulation 1008/2008, which protects airlines’ freedom to set fares and ancillary charges.
A similar scenario came up in June 2025 when a Spanish court temporarily suspended the fines for Ryanair, Norwegian, and Vueling, pending further judicial review. That injunction allows those airlines to continue applying their baggage surcharges, although they were asked to deposit bank guarantees totalling over €110 million.
At the same time, a court in Salamanca ordered Ryanair to refund a passenger €147 for hand-luggage fees paid across five flights. The judge stated that carry-on luggage is “an essential element of passenger transport” and should not incur a surcharge.
Now, the legal battle rests on two forces: Spain’s consumer law claims plus court rulings favouring passengers, versus the Commission’s insistence on preserving airline pricing freedom.
A Balancing Act
While both sides work to make sense of the issue, the core of the dispute lies in how national regulations intersect with overarching EU laws. The reliance on ancillary revenue, like bags, seat fees, and priority boarding, is not a new practice for low-cost business models. However, if the EU rules put a cap on these streams, base fares may need to shift upward.
Carriers must now monitor not only national courts but also EU authorities. An adverse ruling from the Commission or from the Court could force revisions across all airlines operating in Spain, and possibly influence similar national moves elsewhere.
In a scenario where Brussels prevails, other member states could face pressure to reverse restrictive consumer policies that conflict with airline pricing autonomy. The Commission’s action aligns with its commitment to defend the internal market and ensure consistent enforcement of aviation rules.
Enjoying the article?
Follow us and never miss an update on the aviation industry.
The issue remains important as it connects to ongoing EU discussions about passenger rights. The European Parliament’s transport committee has voted in favour of requiring all airlines flying within the EU to allow free hand baggage. Passengers can have one item up to 7 kg, plus a small personal bag. However, this rule hasn't become law yet. The Council of the EU currently supports giving airlines the choice to charge if they want. Until a final decision is made, baggage rules will continue to vary between airlines.
In the meantime, airlines operating in Spain may face legal uncertainty. If Spanish courts begin enforcing local consumer protection rulings that go against the EU Commission’s stance, it could create conflict.
The Bottom Line
The Spanish government’s stance is rooted in consumer protection. But the European Commission’s involvement shows the tenuous nature of air travel regulations within the European Union. For aviation professionals from entry-level to leadership, this isn’t just a regulatory dispute - it could reshape how ancillary revenue is governed across Europe.
